← Articles

$40 to Grade a Card. Four Months to Get It Back. And Collectors Are Celebrating

PSA made a big announcement last week.

Value grading is back.

Collectors can once again submit cards through one of PSA's lower-priced service levels.

The price?

$39.99 per card.

The estimated turnaround?

90–100 business days.

That's roughly four to five months before accounting for shipping and other potential delays.

And somehow, this is being treated as good news.

I think we've completely lost perspective.


Remember When $33 Was Expensive?

Before PSA suspended Value submissions in June, the service cost $32.99 per card.

Now it's $39.99.

That's a 21% increase.

Meanwhile, the cheaper Value Bulk option remains unavailable.

So after nearly five months without Value grading, collectors are being welcomed back with a higher price and a turnaround estimate measured in months.

PSA says it's making progress on its enormous backlog. That's true.

But let's not confuse a company improving its operations with collectors getting a great deal.

We're paying more for a service we were previously paying less to receive.

And we're supposed to be excited about that?


Do the Math Before You Celebrate

Let's say you have ten raw cards worth $30 each.

That's $300 in cardboard.

Send all ten through PSA's reopened Value service, and you're spending another $399.90 just on grading.

You now have nearly $700 tied up in those cards before shipping, insurance, or selling fees.

And you could be waiting months to get them back.

For that decision to make financial sense, the market needs to reward those grades enough to cover the additional expense.

Some cards will.

Others won't.

And the grading company gets paid either way.

That's the part of this business model collectors should think about more often.

The company sells the service.

The collector takes the gamble.


Seven Million Cards Still Waiting

PSA's latest reported active backlog stands at 7.2 million cards.

That's down significantly from its July peak of approximately 12.4 million.

Credit where it's due. PSA has increased production and reduced the backlog.

But 7.2 million cards is still an extraordinary number.

And PSA itself acknowledges that too many existing submissions have exceeded their estimated turnaround times.

Think about what that means.

Millions of cards are moving through a system that collectors voluntarily pay to participate in.

Not because the cards need repairing.

Not because their condition improves.

But because the market has attached enormous importance to the number that comes back.


We've Made Grading Too Important

Here's what bothers me most.

PSA isn't hiding its prices.

It's publishing its turnaround estimates.

It's telling collectors exactly what they're signing up for.

And collectors continue lining up.

That tells me this isn't simply a PSA problem.

It's a hobby problem.

We've created a market where collectors feel compelled to spend money on grading because they fear leaving value on the table.

We've made the label so important that waiting months and paying $40 for an opinion can feel like a necessary investment.

But necessary to whom?

The card doesn't need the label.

The market has been trained to want it.

There's a difference.


Maybe the Best Grading Decision Is Not to Grade

Before you submit your next card, ask yourself something.

Would I still want this card if grading didn't exist?

Would I appreciate its condition without a number?

Would I buy it raw at a fair price?

And would I be comfortable owning it if nobody ever sealed it in plastic?

If the answer is yes, you've already identified what makes the card worth having.

I'm not pretending grading premiums don't exist.

They do.

But every time we chase those premiums without questioning the cost, we reinforce the very system that created them.

PSA has reopened Value grading.

That's news.

The bigger story is that we've reached a point where paying $40 and waiting months for a number feels like a bargain.

That should tell us everything about how far this hobby has drifted.

Stop celebrating access to the grading machine.

Start questioning why we believe we need it.

Get the next Opinion in your inbox

One article a week. No spam.