← Articles

PSA Has 6.8 Million Cards Waiting. Why Are We Making More?

PSA released another backlog update on November 3.

The good news? Its backlog dropped from 7.2 million cards to 6.8 million.

The bad news?

Collectors are already sending in enough new cards to slow the recovery.

PSA acknowledged that increased submissions following the reopening of its Value service contributed to a slower reduction in the backlog.

Think about that.

Millions of cards are waiting to be graded.

Collectors are paying $39.99 per card for Value service.

Estimated turnaround times are still 90–100 business days.

And the submissions keep coming.

At some point, we need to stop asking how quickly PSA can grade cards and start asking why we're sending so many in the first place.


The Backlog Is Becoming the Business

PSA deserves credit for reducing its backlog from a July peak of 12.4 million cards.

That's substantial progress.

But consider what the company disclosed in its October 28 announcement.

PSA graded approximately 59 million items over the previous three years.

That's more than the 57 million it graded during the preceding 23 years combined.

Read that again.

Three years of grading exceeded more than two decades of previous production.

The industry calls that growth.

I call it evidence of how dependent the hobby has become on plastic holders and numbered labels.


How Many of Those Cards Actually Needed Grading?

That's the question nobody seems interested in asking.

Of those millions of submissions, how many were genuinely rare?

How many were historically significant?

How many needed authentication because counterfeiting was a legitimate concern?

And how many were ordinary modern cards submitted because somebody hoped for a PSA 10?

We don't have a reliable breakdown.

But the distinction matters.

Authentication can answer a legitimate question about whether a collectible is genuine.

Condition grading assigns a standardized opinion about its physical state.

Those are different services.

Somewhere along the way, the hobby started treating them as equally necessary.

They aren't.

A modern card doesn't automatically need professional grading just because somebody hopes to sell it for more money.


We've Created an Endless Cycle

Here's how the system works.

Collectors pay premiums for PSA 10s.

Those premiums encourage more people to submit cards.

More submissions create more graded inventory.

More graded inventory reinforces the idea that raw cards are somehow incomplete.

And the cycle continues.

The grading companies don't have to convince collectors to participate anymore.

Collectors convince each other.

Every time somebody says a raw card is only worth buying if it can grade a 10, they're reinforcing the system.

Every time a seller describes a beautiful raw card as a "PSA 10 candidate," they're doing the same thing.

We've turned the possibility of a grade into a selling feature.

And now we're surprised that millions of cards are waiting for one.


The Most Important Number Isn't 6.8 Million

PSA is working to reduce its backlog to 5 million cards before considering the return of additional lower-priced services.

That's its operational target.

But here's mine.

Zero.

Not zero cards graded across the entire hobby.

Zero cards submitted simply because a collector feels obligated to chase a label.

Zero cards sent away because somebody believes raw automatically means inferior.

Zero collectors convinced that their own judgment is worthless without corporate validation.

That's the change I'd like to see.

Not faster grading.

Not cheaper grading.

Less dependence on grading.


Stop Measuring the Hobby by the Number of Slabs

PSA will eventually work through its backlog.

Its facilities will become more efficient.

Turnaround times may improve.

And millions more cards will probably enter the system.

But none of that answers the question that matters.

Are we building a better hobby, or just a bigger grading industry?

Those aren't necessarily the same thing.

A hobby filled with collectors who understand condition, appreciate great cards, and trust their own judgment doesn't need millions of new plastic holders to thrive.

It needs people willing to think independently.

The next time you're about to submit a card, ask yourself one question.

Am I grading this card because it needs grading, or because the market has convinced me it does?

The answer might save you $40.

More importantly, it might help you remember who this hobby is supposed to belong to.

Not PSA.

Not the grading industry.

The collectors.

Get the next Opinion in your inbox

One article a week. No spam.