← Articles

PSA Owns the Competition. And Collectors Should Be Asking Questions.

Imagine walking into a card show and discovering that three competing dealers all have the same owner.

Different signs.

Different prices.

Different sales pitches.

But the money ultimately goes to the same place.

Would you still consider them competitors?

Because that's essentially what's happened in the sports card grading industry.

PSA, SGC, and Beckett now share the same parent company: Collectors Holdings.

And the hobby should be paying a lot more attention.


Three Brands. One Owner.

Collectors acquired SGC in 2024.

Then came Beckett in 2025.

PSA was already the dominant grading company.

Now three of the hobby's most recognizable grading brands sit under the same corporate umbrella.

CGC remains a major independent competitor.

But the consolidation is significant enough that Congressman Pat Ryan called for a federal antitrust investigation, warning that the combined business could control more than 80% of grading volume.

That figure was an estimate, not a definitive finding.

Still, consider what we're talking about.

A private company with enormous influence over how collectors buy, sell, and value their cards has acquired two of its best-known rivals.

And we're supposed to treat that like ordinary business news?


The Legal Challenges Are Getting Serious

This isn't just collectors arguing on social media.

Collectors Holdings is facing multiple lawsuits involving its grading businesses.

One alleges that the acquisitions of SGC and Beckett harmed competition.

Other lawsuits challenge grading practices and raise conflict-of-interest allegations.

A November 14 update from Cardboard Journal highlighted three separate cases.

None of those allegations has been proven in court.

And allegations aren't evidence of wrongdoing.

But the existence of these disputes raises an important question.

How much authority should one private company have in a market where its opinions can influence thousands of dollars in value?

Because that's the position we've allowed grading companies to occupy.


Who Benefits When Competition Disappears?

Competition is supposed to give customers choices.

Better prices.

Faster service.

Different standards.

More accountability.

But when competing brands share an owner, the incentives change.

They can still operate differently.

They can still offer separate services.

But they no longer represent the same kind of independent competition.

And collectors should understand that distinction.

If you're unhappy with PSA and move your submissions to SGC or Beckett, you haven't necessarily moved your business away from the company that owns PSA.

You've changed brands.

Not corporate ownership.

That's a pretty important detail for an industry built around consumer trust.


The Bigger Problem Isn't Corporate Ownership

Here's where I think the hobby needs to look in the mirror.

Collectors helped create this situation.

We made PSA grades a powerful factor in resale value.

We made population reports part of buying decisions.

We made grading premiums so important that a company's judgment could dramatically influence what buyers would pay.

And now we're watching that influence become increasingly concentrated.

The problem isn't simply that one company owns multiple grading brands.

The problem is that we've given grading companies so much authority that their ownership structure can matter to the entire hobby.

Think about how absurd that is.

We're collecting sports cards.

Pieces of cardboard featuring athletes, teams, and moments in history.

Yet we've built a market where corporate grading decisions can have more influence on prices than the cards themselves.


What Happens When Collectors Stop Playing Along?

There's something the grading companies can't acquire.

Your judgment.

They can't force you to submit a card.

They can't force you to pay a PSA 10 premium.

They can't force you to believe a beautiful raw card is inferior because it doesn't have a number.

Collectors created the demand that made grading companies powerful.

And collectors still control their own buying decisions.

I'm not suggesting every graded card is worthless.

I'm questioning why we've allowed grading companies to become so central to determining what cards are worth.

That's a distinction the hobby needs to understand.

Because this isn't just about PSA anymore.

It's about who gets to define value in a market built by collectors.

The card belongs to you.

The grading company owns the label.

Don't let them own your judgment, too.

Get the next Opinion in your inbox

One article a week. No spam.